Abstract

The real impact of wage fluctuations can only be appreciated when “nominal” (i.e., actual) wages and changes in the cost of living are taken into account. For example, if a worker’s nominal wages rise during a given period but the cost of living rises even more, then his or her “real wages” have declined. This table shows how these factors interrelate. A period of relative economic stagnation occurred after 1873; here, we can see its effects in the years 1875–1880: although the cost-of-living index declined somewhat in this half-decade, indicating a period of price deflation, nominal wages declined even more. Hence, German workers’ average real wages declined from 578 to 524 marks, and the index of real wages (taking 1895 prices as 100) fell from 87 to 79. That index rose quickly during the “mini-boom” of the last half of the 1880s, and then more slowly during the “mini-bust” of the early 1890s. These increases may have been small, but except for the half-decade from 1875 to 1880 they were never negative. Hence, historians have revised previous assessments that spoke of a “Great Depression” during these years.

The period 1873–1896 was both preceded and followed by boom years, leading many contemporary Germans to perceive these intervening years as a time of uncommon hardship. Note the dramatic increases in both nominal and real wages in the period 1895 to 1913, during which time the index of real wages rose 25%, from 100 in 1895 to 125 in 1913. These statistics nevertheless obscure important variations in the earning potential of workers in different economic sectors and regions of the country. They also obscure the ever-present danger of calamity if unemployment, injury, sickness, or the death of the primary breadwinner caused a loss of earnings.

Nominal Wages, Cost of Living, and Real Wages in Industry, Trade, and Transportation (1871–1913)

  • Ashok Desai

Source

The Average Annual Wages of Employees in Industry, Trade, and Transportation[1]

Year

1. Average
annual wages
(nominal)
in marks

1. Average
annual wages
(nominal)
1895 = 100

2. Cost-of-living
index[2]

1895 = 100

3. Average
annual wages
(real)
in 1895 prices

3. Average
annual wages
(real)
1895 = 100

1871

493

74

105.8

466

70

1875

651

98

112.7

578

87

1880

545

82

104.0

524

79

1885

581

87

98.6

589

89

1890

650

98

102.2

636

96

1895

665

100

100.0

665

100

1900

784

118

106.4

737

111

1905

849

128

112.4

755

114

1910

979

147

124.2

789

119

1913

1,083

163

129.8

834

125

Source: Ashok V. Desai, Real Wages in Germany 1871–1913. Oxford, 1968, pp. 112, 117, 125.

The calculation of the percentages in columns 1 and 3 was done by the editors [Gerd Hohorst, Jürgen Kocka und Gerhard A. Ritter]. In column 3, they deviate slightly from the index figures for the years 1871 and 1885 (66 and 88, respectively) provided by Desai, p. 36. Original German table reprinted in Gerd Hohorst, Jürgen Kocka, and Gerhard A. Ritter, Sozialgeschichtliches Arbeitsbuch II, 2nd ed. Munich: Beck, 1978, pp. 107–08.

Notes

[1] Not considered in the table: farm workers, those employed in cottage industry and domestic service, civil servants, and workers and salaried employees whose annual income was high enough that their employers were not required to pay contributions into the mandatory accident insurance fund established by the Accident Insurance Law of 1884 (and its supplements). In most industries, this income limit was 3,000 until 1913. For further restrictions on the group of employees recorded before 1886, see Hohorst et al., pp. 107–08.
[2] In calculating the cost of living, Desai assumes a broader basis than other scholars by including clothing, fuel, and lighting.
Translation: Erwin Fink