Abstract
Just a few days before victorious Prussian troops staged their
victory parade through the Brandenburg Gate (September 21, 1866),
Bismarck and other Berlin notables attended the dedication of the new
Jewish synagogue on Oranienburger Strasse. It was built according to
plans by Eduard Knoblauch and Friedrich August Stüler in the years
1859–66. With its huge, gilded dome, crowned with a Star of David, the
synagogue immediately assumed a commanding place in the Berlin skyline.
Just as the Prussians’ victory march symbolized the triumph of German
unification under the Hohenzollerns, the dedication of the synagogue
marked the emergence of Berlin as a world-class capital and the coming
of age of the city’s vibrant Jewish community. Between 1864 and 1874,
the Jewish population of Berlin almost doubled, from 24,000 to 45,000.
Yet to Berliners and other Germans who resented the Jews’ new-found
economic and cultural influence, their alien, “Oriental” character was
reflected in the synagogue’s quasi-Moorish architecture, which was
intended to evoke the Golden Age of Jewish life in Islamic Spain. Late
nineteenth-century historians such as Heinrich von Treitschke and Werner
Sombart recognized the strongly urban nature of German Judaism, but they
were also among the many Germans who argued that the Jews would always
remain true to their nomadic, “Asiatic” origins. Thus, Treitschke’s
famous polemic of November 1879, “The Jews are our misfortune,” was
preceded by negative comments about Jewish youths crossing the Oder
River from Poland, or places further east, to peddle trousers in the
streets of Berlin. Treitschke’s mix of bluntness and erudition was a
potent brew. He is purported once to have declared that one knows one
has entered a city when a synagogue appears. He added on another
occasion: “when one considers the characteristic fact that the most
beautiful and magnificent house of worship in the German capital is a
synagogue—which, naturally, is not a reproach directed to the Jews but
the Christians—then one cannot deny that the Jews in Germany are more
powerful than they are in any other country in Western Europe.” (Cited
in Paul Mendes-Flohr, “The Berlin Jew as Cosmopolitan,” in
Berlin Metropolis: Jews and the New
Culture, 1890–1918, edited by
Emily D. Bilski. Berkeley: University of California Press, 1999, pp.
14–31, here pp. 16, 31.)